| 



|

"Each of us must find wisdom in his own way. Mine is one way, yours another. Perhaps we each need more of what the other knows." . . . The Lonely Men
The Official Louis L'Amour Discussion Forum
UnknownSackett
Member since 5-17-08
227 posts |
01-15-12, 07:12 PM (Pacific Time) |
 |
8. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
LAST EDITED ON 01-15-12 AT 07:12 PM (Pacific Time) To Tame A Land Bendigo Shafter The Lonesome Gods Reilly's Luck Utah Blaine The Daybreakers Catlow Kilkenny Sackett Brand To the Far Blue Mountainsno particular order the list changes regularly. |
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
Your LL top ten [View All],
10987654321, 07:48 PM, 01-14-12, (0)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
Derek, 01-14-12, 08:08 PM, (1)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
Pistolero, 01-14-12, 10:20 PM, (3)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
TOM, 01-14-12, 11:26 PM, (4)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
Tennessee Dave, 01-15-12, 04:00 PM, (5)
- All are great books..,
RickM, 01-15-12, 04:13 PM, (6)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
UnknownSackett, 01-15-12, 07:12 PM, (8)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
Phyllis, 01-16-12, 07:20 AM, (9)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
epeterd, 01-17-12, 10:48 AM, (17)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
FuwaFuwaUsagi, 01-21-12, 09:48 PM, (18)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
JT, 01-22-12, 09:40 PM, (19)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
explore, 01-24-12, 04:39 AM, (20)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
Longrifle Joe, 01-25-12, 09:43 AM, (22)
- RE: Your LL top ten,
EthanHunt, 02-19-12, 07:32 PM, (23)
|
Derek
Member since 8-16-08
463 posts |
01-14-12, 08:08 PM (Pacific Time) |
|
1. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
I think that we have LD, but no harm ever in doing it again. Due to being no spring chicken my list would probably change somewhat, memery not what it used to be. Anyway, here goes. (in no particular order)1. Flint 2.The Daybreakers 3.Sackett 4.Conagher 5. Shalako 6.The Sackett Brand 7.The Man From Broken Hills 8.Comstock Lode 9.Hondo 10.Crossfire Trail Tough one, LD. I left some really good ones out, as I'm sure you did too. " The only time a man should be dancing is when other men are shooting at his feet. "
|
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
TOM
Member since 9-6-05
559 posts |
01-14-12, 11:26 PM (Pacific Time) |
 |
4. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
My list of favorites change all the time, but here goes... (in no particular order) 1. Westward the Tide 2. Flint 3. To Tame a Land 4. Last Stand at Papago Wells 5. Sackett 6. The Daybreakers 7. Sacketts Brand 8. Hondo 9. Down the Long Hills 10. Conagher 5 honorable mentions. 11. Kilkenny 12. Comstock Lode 13. Bendigo Shafter 14. The Lonesome Gods 15. Sitka TOM |
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
Tennessee Dave
Member since 1-2-11
1227 posts |
01-15-12, 04:00 PM (Pacific Time) |
 |
5. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
It's difficult for me to name 10 LL's that I don't like. Tennessee Dave "Change is inevitable, growth is optional." Author unknown |
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
UnknownSackett
Member since 5-17-08
227 posts |
01-15-12, 07:12 PM (Pacific Time) |
 |
8. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
LAST EDITED ON 01-15-12 AT 07:12 PM (Pacific Time) To Tame A Land Bendigo Shafter The Lonesome Gods Reilly's Luck Utah Blaine The Daybreakers Catlow Kilkenny Sackett Brand To the Far Blue Mountainsno particular order the list changes regularly. |
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
 |
DocKaty
Member since 12-6-09
625 posts |
01-16-12, 09:32 AM (Pacific Time) |
|
10. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #9
| |
LAST EDITED ON 01-16-12 AT 09:33 AM (Pacific Time) I have to go along with Phyllis on this one. When you have over 100 novels in the excellent category, it is no small task to pick the 10 best. Although I must confess that Westward the Tide always come to mind whenever I think of LL westerns. To me, there always has to be a beautiful woman involved that eventually realizes the man she has spurned is the one she loves.****************************************** May we live to learn well, and learn to live well. May you live as long as you want, and never want as long as you live.
|
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
 |
DocKaty
Member since 12-6-09
625 posts |
01-16-12, 12:10 PM (Pacific Time) |
|
13. "LL top ten- Guns of the Timberland"
In response to message #12
| |
I thought the movie version with Alan Ladd and Jeanne Crain (filmed around Williams,Arizona) was pretty good. ****************************************** May we live to learn well, and learn to live well. May you live as long as you want, and never want as long as you live.
|
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
|
FuwaFuwaUsagi
Member since 11-26-07
69 posts |
01-21-12, 09:48 PM (Pacific Time) |
 |
18. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
This was really, really tough. The reality is there are about 15 books I find as his finest, in terms of enjoyable reads. Here is my list of favorites: Passin' Through Ride the Dark Trail The Proving Trail Over on the Dry Side Mustang Man The Tall Stranger The Key-Lock Man Guns of the Timberlands North to the Rails Tucker
As I mentioned I could have easily bumped that list out by another 5. That being said, enjoyable reads are not necessarily L'Amour at his finest, IMO. I think Louis L'Amour's three finest books are: Sackett’s Land The Burning Hills Reilly's Luck they are not my favorites per sey, but they are excellent in their category/theme. I'll probably break this out into another thread at some point but I think he wrote five distinct themes in terms of western fiction. 1) The quintessential loner 2) Group cooperation stories 3) The historiography 4) Coming of age stories 5) Pure entertainment/Yarns/tales (mostly the short stories) I almost included Hondo and How the West was Won but I am not sure how much L'Amour is really in those. They do not strike true to me. |
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
JT
Member since 9-29-08
269 posts |
01-22-12, 09:40 PM (Pacific Time) |
 |
19. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
I'm kind of shocked and puzzled that only one other person has mentioned Sackett's Land. I think I read and re-read it at least a dozen times. Oh, well. Here's my list: 1) Sackett's Land 2) The Daybreakers 3) Jubal Sackett 4) Sackett 5) The Sackett Brand 6) The Lonesome Gods 7) Comstock Lode 8) Flint 9) North to the Rails 9) Crossfire Trail 10) Fair Blows the Wind |
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
explore
Member since 1-2-11
285 posts |
01-24-12, 04:39 AM (Pacific Time) |
 |
20. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
Mine are: Flint Empty Land Daybreakers Sacket Brand Hondo Shalako Mojave Crossing Last of the Breed Guns of the Timberlands Conagher
Explorer A nation of sheep breeds a government of wolves |
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
Longrifle Joe
Member since 9-6-05
932 posts |
01-25-12, 09:43 AM (Pacific Time) |
 |
22. "RE: Your LL top ten"
In response to message #0
| |
Like many others here, I have read LL's Western stories over and over, and continue to do. I like most all of them, but of course, some more than others. Here is my attempt to list my top ten while recognizing that one or two of them may change over time. 1.To Tame A Land 2.Flint 3.Reilly's Luck 4.Bendigo Shafter 5.Mustang Man 6.The Sackett Brand 7.Under The Sweetwater Rim 8.Last of The Breed 9.The Warrior's Path 10.The First Fast Draw I purchased the hardback "Collected Short Stories" as they became available and especially enjoy reading the Frontier stories. In my opinion, LL was a natural for that genre. I have found very few Western Stories by other authors which strike a level of realism for me that is close to that of LL. "Lonesome Dove" by McMurtry comes close as do a couple of stories by Matt Braun. Most of the current Western genre writers cannot hold my attention for a full length story but I continue to read and re-read LL's Western stories over and over---I almost know them by heart. LRJ Longrifle Joe |
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|